Doomed from the start – the ASEAN Human Rights Declaration (LoyarBurok)

This article was published in Loyarburok.

Doomed from the start

Doomed from the start – the AHRD | Badly drawn by Yu Ren Chung. Original picture from http://jvsc.jst.go.jp/find/sports_e/s02_sld/d2_mech/m40_tx.htm

Last week, Prime Minister Najib Razak and other ASEAN leaders signed a document called the ASEAN Human Rights Declaration, or more fondly, the “AHRD”. In the ensuing days, much was said about the AHRD. ASEAN and governments praised it, the United Nations expressed caution, and civil society condemned it.

Many are disappointed with the Declaration, as am I. But honestly, were our expectations that high to begin with?

The AHRD was doomed from the start – doomed by poor and varied human rights standards among ASEAN countries coupled with a consensus style decision-making process, ASEAN’s compulsive focus on sovereignty and non-interference, a non-independent human rights commission, and a secretive and non-inclusive drafting process. Continue reading

Quote

Women’s NGOs in SEA oppose “public morality” in the ASEAN Human Rights Declaration (Southeast Asia Women’s Caucus on ASEAN)

In an article by the Southeast Asia Women’s Caucus on ASEAN, opposing the inclusion of “public morality” as a justification to limit human rights in the ASEAN Human Rights Declaration, I comment on how moral policing laws discriminate against women in Malaysia:

Yu Ren Chung, Program Officer of Women’s Aid Organization in Malaysia cited how “public morality” under Syariah laws was used by the state in policing Muslims in his country, citing indecency, liwat (sodomy), musahaqah (lesbianism), drinking alcohol, khalwat (intimate acts of unmarried couples), zina (sex out of wedlock), and not observing fasting during the fasting month as acts violating these laws.

“These laws discriminate on the basis of gender identity as the Syariah Criminal offences include any male person who, in any public place, wears a woman’s attire and poses as a woman for immoral purposes and shall on conviction be liable to a fine not exceeding one thousand ringgit or to imprisonment for a term not exceeding one year or both,” Yu said.

Malaysia’s civil laws are also used to police non-Muslims. Yu shared an incident in March 2012 when three women were charged for indecent behavior for doing pole dancing in a nightclub in Seremban. The women were fined RM25 each and charged for allegedly being “dressed scantily”.

Update: Unfortunately, the term “public morality” was retained in the final Declaration. In fact, the entire Declaration was largely disappointing, as I describe in this Loyarburok post.

Read the full article published on the Southeast Asia Women’s Caucus on ASEAN blog on 20 September 2012.